WORKERS COMPENSATION RULES OF THE
NORTH CAROLINA INDUSTRIAL COMMISSION
Revisions Effective 1 August 2006*
TABLE OF CONTENTS
*Click here to view the annotated version of these
rules, effective 1 June 2000, with
revisions to Rules 104, 404A, 501, 502, 601, 701, 702, and 903
effective 1 August 2006. Additions are
indicated in bold italic type, and deletions are indicated in strikethrough
type. |
ARTICLE I. ADMINISTRATION
Rule 101
Location of Offices and Hours of Business
The offices of the North Carolina Industrial Commission
(hereinafter "Industrial Commission") are located in the Dobbs Building, 430
North Salisbury Street, in Raleigh, North Carolina. The General Mailing Address is North
Carolina Industrial Commission, 4319 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-4319.
The same office hours will be observed by the Industrial Commission as are, or may
be, observed by other State offices in Raleigh. The offices are open between
the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. to accept documents for filing.
Rule 102
Transaction of Business by the Commission
The Industrial Commission will remain in continuous session subject to the call of the
Chair to meet as a body for the purpose of transacting such business as may come before
it.
In reviewing an Opinion and Award of a Deputy Commissioner or of a sole Commissioner
acting as the hearing officer, the Full Commission may sit en banc or in panels of three.
Rule 103
Official Forms
- The Industrial Commission will supply, on request, forms identified by number and title
as follows: [Note: To view or print PDF versions of these forms, you must
download and install a free Adobe® Acrobat®
Reader.]
Form 17Workers
Compensation Notice
Form 18Notice
of Accident to Employer and Claim of Employee or His Personal Representative or Dependents
(N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-22 through 24) [N.C. Gen. Stat. §§97-22,
97-23, and 97-24.]
Form 18BClaim
by Employee or His Personal Representative or Dependents for Workers Compensation
Benefits for Lung Damage, Including Asbestosis, Silicosis, and Byssinosis (N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-53)
Form 18MEmployees
Claim for Additional Medical Compensation
Form 19Employers
Report of Employees Injury to the Industrial Commission
Form 21Agreement
for Compensation for Disability Pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-82
Form 22Statement
of Days Worked and Earnings of Injured Employee (Wage Chart)
Form 24Application
to Terminate or Suspend Payment of Compensation Pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-18.1
Form 25CAuthorization
for Rehabilitation Professional to Obtain Medical Records of Current Treatment
Form 25DDentists
Itemized Statement of Charges for Treatment and Certification of Treatment of Disability
Form 25MPhysicians
Itemized Statement of Charges for Treatment and Certification of Treatment
Form 25NNotice
to the Industrial Commission of Assignment of Rehabilitation Professional
Form 25PItemized
Statement of Charges for Drugs
Form 25REvaluation
for Permanent Impairment
Form 25TItemized
Statement of Charges for Travel
Form UB-92Hospital Bill
Form 26Supplemental
Agreement as to Payment of Compensation Pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-82
Form 26DAgreement
for Compensation Under N.C.
Gen. Stat. §97-37
Form 28Return
to Work Report
Form 28BReport
of Employer or Carrier/Administrator of Compensation and Medical Compensation Paid and
Notice of Right to Additional Medical Compensation
Form 28TNotice
of Termination of Compensation by Reason of Trial Return to Work Pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-18.1(b) and N.C.
Gen. Stat. §97-32.1
Form 28UEmployees
Request that Compensation be Reinstated After Unsuccessful Trial Return to Work Pursuant
to N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-32.1
Form 29Supplementary
Report for Fatal Accidents
Form 30Agreement
for Compensation for Death
Form 30DNotice
of Death Award (Approval of Agreement)
Form 31Application
for Lump Sum Award
Form 33Request
that Claim be Assigned for Hearing
Form 33RResponse
to Request that Claim be Assigned for Hearing
Form 36Subpoena
for Witness and Subpoena to Produce Items or Documents
Form 42Application
for Appointment of Guardian Ad Litem
Form 44Application
for Review
Form 50Itemized
Statement of Charge for Nursing
Form 51Consolidated
Fiscal Annual Report of "Medical Only" and "Lost Time" Cases
Form 60Employers
Admission of Employees Right to Compensation Pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-18(b)
Form 61Denial
of Workers Compensation Claim Pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-18(c) and (d)
Form 62Notice
of Reinstatement of Compensation Pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-32.1
and N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-18(b)
Form 63Notice
to Employee of Payment of Compensation Without Prejudice to Later Deny the Claim Pursuant
to N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-18(d)
Form 90Report
of Earnings
Form IZ-510Medical Bill Analysis Used for Approval and Reduction of
Medical Bills
Form MCS2Petition
for Order Referring Case to Mediated Settlement Conference
Form MCS4Designation
of Mediator
Form MCS5Report
of Mediator
Form MCS6Mediators
Declaration of Interest and Qualifications
Form MCS7Report
of Evaluator
The mailing address for each Industrial Commission form appears at the bottom right
corner of the Form.
- The use of any printed forms other than those approved and adopted by the Industrial
Commission is prohibited. Insurance carriers, self-insureds, attorneys and other parties
may reproduce approved forms for their own use, provided:
- No statement, question, or information blank contained on the approved Industrial
Commissions form is omitted from the substituted form.
- Such substituted form is substantially identical in size and format with the approved
Industrial Commissions form.
- The following forms may be utilized in preparing routine orders for the signature of a
Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner, and are appended at the end of these Rules: [Note:
PDF versions of these forms will eventually be listed below. To view or print PDF versions
of these forms, you must download and install a free Adobe® Acrobat®
Reader.]
Form IOrder
for Third Party Recovery Distribution per N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-10.2
Form IIOrder
Approving Compromise Settlement Agreement (admitted liability, medical paid) and Third
Party Distribution
Form IIIOrder
for Approving Compromise Settlement Agreements (admitted liability, medical paid)
- Copies of rules, forms and Industrial Commission Minutes can be obtained by contacting
the Administrators Office of the Industrial Commission, 4319 Mail Service Center,
Raleigh, NC 27699-4319.
Rule 104
Employers Report of Injury
An employer shall immediately report to its carrier or
administrator any injury or occupational disease, or allegation by an employee
of an injury or occupational disease, sustained in the course of employment for
which the attention of a physician is needed or actually sought. Within five
days of knowledge of the injury or allegation, the employer or
carrier/administrator or its successor in interest shall file with the
Industrial Commission and provide a copy to the employee of a
Form 19,
Employer’s Report of Employee’s Injury to the Industrial Commission, if
injury causes the employee to be absent from work for more than one day or the employee’s medical compensation is greater than an amount which is
established periodically by the Industrial Commission in its Minutes. The
employer may record the employee’s or another person’s description of the injury
on the Form 19
without admitting the truth of the information.
In addition to providing
the Form 19 to
the employee, the employer or carrier/administrator shall also provide a
blank Form 18
for use by the employee.
The front of the
Form 19 shall
prominently display the following statement: “To the Employee: This
Form 19 is not
your claim for workers’ compensation benefits. To make a claim, you must
complete and sign the enclosed Form 18 and mail
it to the Claims Section, North Carolina Industrial Commission, 4334 Mail
Service Center, Raleigh, NC 28799-4334 within two years of the date of your
injury or last payment of medical compensation. For occupational diseases, the
claim must be filed within two years of the date of disability and the date your
doctor told you that you have a work-related disease, whichever is later.”
ARTICLE II. NOTICE OF ACT
Rule 201
Notice of Employment Subject to the Act
- Pursuant to the provisions of N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-93,
all employers subject to the provisions of the Workers Compensation Act shall post
in a conspicuous location in places of employment a Form 17, Workers
Compensation Notice, to give notice to the employees that they are in an employment
subject to the provisions of the Workers Compensation Act and that their employer
has obtained workers compensation coverage or has qualified as self-insured for
workers compensation purposes.
- Should the employer allow its workers compensation coverage to lapse or cease to
qualify as a self-insured, the employer shall remove within five working days any Form 17 and any other notice
indicating otherwise.
ARTICLE III. INSURANCE
Rule 301
Proof of Insurance Coverage
Every employer subject to the provisions of the Act shall file with the
Industrial Commission proof that it has obtained workers compensation insurance
pursuant to the insurance provisions of the Act. This requirement may be
satisfied by:
- A notice from the employers insurance carrier, through the North Carolina Rate
Bureau, certifying that coverage has been received.
- A notice from the North Carolina Department of Insurance, through the Rate Bureau,
certifying that the employer has qualified as a self-insured employer or as a member of a
self-insurance fund pursuant to the Act.
- All employers have an affirmative obligation to report to the Rate Bureau any changes in
coverage within 30 days.
- All employers must notify the Department of Insurance when it becomes a member of a
self-insurance fund.
ARTICLE IV. DISABILITY, COMPENSATION, FEES
Rule 401
When Disability Begins for Purpose of Computing Compensation
- If the injured employee is not paid wages for the entire day on which the injury
occurred, the seven-day waiting period prescribed by the Act shall include the day of
injury regardless of the hour of the injury.
- If the injured employee is paid wages for the entire day on which he is injured and
fails to return to work on his next regular workday because of the injury, the seven-day
waiting period shall begin with the first calendar day following his injury, even though
this may or may not be a regularly scheduled workday.
- All days, or parts of days, when the injured employee is unable to earn a full
days wages, or is not paid a full days wages due to injury, shall be counted
in computing the waiting period even though the days may not be consecutive, and even
though these are not regularly scheduled workdays.
- If the permanent disability period, when added to the temporary disability period,
exceeds 21 days, there is no waiting period.
Rule 402
Computation of Daily Wage
In all cases involving a fractional part of a week, the daily wage shall be computed on
the basis of one-seventh of the average weekly wage.
Rule 403
Manner of Payment of Compensation
- All payments of compensation must be made directly to the employee, dependent, guardian
or personal representative entitled thereto unless otherwise ordered by the Industrial
Commission. At the employees request, payment of compensation shall be mailed by
first class mail, postage pre-paid, to an address specified by the employee, unless
otherwise directed by the Industrial Commission.
- All payments of compensation must be made in strict accordance with the award issued by
the Industrial Commission.
Rule 404
Termination of Compensation
- Payments of compensation undertaken pursuant to an award of the Industrial Commission
shall continue until the terms of the award have been fully satisfied. In cases where the
award is to pay compensation during disability, there is a rebuttable presumption that
disability continues until the employee returns to suitable employment. No application to
terminate or suspend compensation shall be approved without a formal hearing if the effect
of such approval is to set aside the provisions of an award of the Industrial Commission.
- When an employer or carrier/administrator seeks to terminate or suspend compensation
being paid pursuant to N.C.
Gen. Stat. §97-29 for a reason other than those specified in N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-18(d), payment without prejudice, or N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-18.1(b), trial return to work, the employer or carrier/administrator shall notify
the employee and the employees attorney of record, if any, on Form 24, "Application to
Stop Payment of Compensation." The employer or carrier/administrator shall specify
the legal grounds and the alleged facts supporting the application, and shall complete the
blank space in the "Important Notice to Employee" portion of Form 24 by inserting a date
17 days from the date the employer or carrier/administrator deposits the completed Form 24 in the mail to the
employee and the employees attorney of record, if any. The original of the Form 24 and the attached
documents shall be sent to the Industrial Commission at the same time and by the same
method by which a copy of the Form
24 and attached documents are sent to the employee and the employees attorney of
record, if any. The Form 24
shall specify the number of pages of documents attached which are to be considered by the
Industrial Commission. Failure to specify the number of pages may result in the refusal of
the Industrial Commission to accept the same for filing. If the employee or the
employees attorney of record, if any, objects by the date inserted on the
employers Form 24,
or within such additional reasonable time as the Industrial Commission may allow, the
Industrial Commission shall set the case for an informal hearing, unless
waived by the parties in favor of a formal hearing. A copy of any objection shall be sent,
with any supporting documents, to the employer and carrier/administrator. The term
"carrier/administrator" also includes any successor in interest.
- If an employee does not object within the allowed time, the Industrial Commission shall
review the Form 24 and any
attached documentation, and an Administrative Decision and Order may be rendered without
an informal hearing as to whether compensation shall be terminated or suspended, except as
provided in paragraph (6) below. Either party may seek review of the
Administrative Decision and Order as provided by Rule 703.
- If the employee timely objects to the Form 24, the Industrial
Commission shall conduct an informal hearing within 25 days of the receipt by the
Industrial Commission of the Form
24, unless the time is extended for good cause shown. The informal hearing may be by
telephone conference between the Industrial Commission and the parties or their attorneys
of record, if any. When good cause is shown, the informal hearing may be conducted with
the parties or their attorneys of record, if any, personally present with the Industrial
Commission in Raleigh or such other location as is selected by the Industrial Commission.
The Industrial Commission shall make arrangements for the informal hearing with a view
towards conducting the hearing in the most expeditious manner under the circumstances.
Except for good cause shown, the informal hearing shall be no more than 30 minutes, with
each side given 10 minutes to present its case and five minutes for rebuttal.
Notwithstanding the above, the employer or carrier/administrator may waive the right to an
informal hearing, and proceed to a formal hearing by filing a request for hearing on a Form 33. A decision on the
application shall be made within five days after the completion of the informal hearing.
- Either party may appeal the Administrative Decision and Order of the Industrial
Commission as provided by Rule 703. A Deputy Commissioner shall conduct
a hearing which shall be a hearing de novo. The hearing shall be peremptorily set
and shall not require a Form
33. The employer has the burden of producing evidence on the issue of the
employers application for termination or suspension of compensation. If the Deputy
Commissioner reverses an order previously granting a Form 24 motion, the employer
or carrier/administrator shall promptly resume compensation or otherwise comply with the
Deputy Commissioners decision, notwithstanding any appeal or application for review
to the Full Commission under N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-85.
- In the event the Industrial Commission is unable to reach a decision
after an informal hearing, the Industrial Commission shall issue an order to that effect
which shall be in lieu of a Form
33 and the case shall be placed on the formal hearing
docket. If additional issues are to be addressed, the employer or
carrier/administrator shall be required within 30 days of the date of the Administrative
Decision and Order to file a Form
33 or to notify the Industrial Commission that a formal hearing is not currently
necessary. The effect of placing the case on the docket shall be the same as if the Form 24 were denied, and
compensation shall continue until such time as the case is decided by a Commissioner or a
Deputy Commissioner following a formal hearing.
- Any Administrative Decision and Order shall be mailed to the non-prevailing party by
certified mail.
- No order issued as a result of an informal Form 24 hearing shall
terminate or suspend compensation retroactively to a date preceding the filing date of the
Form 24. Compensation may
be terminated retroactively without a formal hearing where there is agreement by the
parties, where allowed by statute, or where the employee is incarcerated. Otherwise,
retroactive termination or suspension of compensation to a date preceding the filing of a Form 24 may be ordered as a
result of a formal hearing. Additionally, nothing shall impair an employers right to
seek a credit pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-42.
Rule 404A
Trial Return to Work
- Except as provided in subparagraph (7), when
compensation for total disability being paid pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-29
is terminated because the employee has returned to work for the same or a different
employer, such termination is subject to the trial return to work provisions of N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-32.1.
When compensation is terminated under these circumstances, the employer or
carrier/administrator shall, within 16 days of the termination of compensation, file a Form 28T with the Industrial
Commission and provide a copy of it to the employee and the employees
attorney of record, if any.
- If during the trial return to work period, the employee must stop
working due to the injury for which compensation had been paid, the employee should
complete and file with the Industrial Commission a Form 28U, without regard to
whether the employer or carrier/administrator has filed a Form 28T as required by paragraph (1) above, and provide a copy of the completed form to the
employer and carrier/administrator. A Form 28U shall contain a
section which must be completed by the physician who imposed the restrictions or one of
the employees authorized treating physicians, certifying that the
employees injury for which compensation had been paid prevents the employee from
continuing the trial return to work. If the employee returned to work with an employer
other than the employer at the time of injury, the employee must complete the
"Employees Release and Request For Employment Information" section of a Form 28U. An employees
failure to provide a Form 28U
does not preclude a subsequent finding by the Commission that the trial return to work was
unsuccessful.
- Upon receipt of a properly completed Form 28U, the employer or
carrier/administrator shall promptly resume payment of compensation for total disability.
If the employee fails to provide the required certification of an authorized treating
physician as specified in subsection 2 above, or if the employee fails
to execute the "Employees Release and Request" section of a Form 28U, if required
pursuant to paragraph (2) above, the employer or carrier/administrator
shall not be required to resume payment of compensation. Instead, in such circumstances,
the employer or carrier/administrator shall promptly return a Form 28U to the employee and
the employees attorney of record, if any, along with a statement explaining the
reason the Form 28U is
being returned and the reason compensation is not being reinstated.
- The reinstated compensation shall be due and payable and subject to the provisions of N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-18(g) on the date and for the period commencing on the date the employer or
carrier/administrator receives a properly completed Form 28U certifying an
unsuccessful return to work. Such resumption of compensation shall not preclude the
employees right to seek, nor the employers or carrier/administrators
right to contest, the payment of compensation for the period prior or subsequent to such
reinstatement. If it is thereafter determined that any temporary total or temporary
partial compensation, including the reinstated compensation, was not due and payable, a
credit shall be given against any other compensation determined to be owed.
- When the employer or carrier/administrator has received a properly completed Form 28U and contests the
employees right to reinstatement of total disability compensation, it may suspend or
terminate compensation only as provided in N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-18.1
and/or pursuant to the provisions of N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-83
and N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-84.
- Upon resumption of payment of compensation for total disability, the employer or
carrier/administrator shall complete and file a Form 62 and/or such other
forms as may be required by the Workers Compensation Act or by Industrial Commission
rule. A copy of the Form 62
shall be sent to the employee and the employees attorney of record, if any.
- The trial return to work provisions do not apply to the following:
-
“Medical only” cases, defined as cases in which the
employee is not absent from work more than one day or in which
medical expenses are less than the amount periodically established by the
Industrial Commission in its Minutes;
- Cases in which the employee has missed fewer than eight days from work;
- Cases wherein the employee has been released to return to work by an authorized treating
physician as specified in subsection 2 above without restriction or
limitation except that if the physician, within 45 days of the employees return to
work date, determines that the employee is not able to perform the job duties assigned,
then the employer or carrier/administrator must resume benefits. If within the same time
period, the physician determines that the employee may work only with restrictions, then
the employee is entitled to a resumption of benefits commencing as of the date of the
report, unless the employer is able to offer employment consistent with the restrictions,
in which case a trial return to work period shall be deemed to have commenced at the time
of the employees initial return to work;
- Cases wherein the employee has accepted or agreed to accept compensation for permanent
partial disability pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-31,
unless the trial return to work follows reinstatement of compensation for total disability
under N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-29; and
- Claims pending on or filed after 1 January 1995, when the employer or
carrier/administrator contests a claim pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-18(d) within the time allowed thereunder.
- This Rule became effective on 15 February 1995, and applies to any employee who leaves
work on or after that date due to a compensable injury.
Rule 405
Computation of Compensation for Amputations
- Amputation of any portion of the bone of a distal phalange of a finger or toe at or
distal to the visible base of the nail will be considered as equivalent to the loss of
one-fourth (¼) of such finger or toe.
- Amputation of any portion of the bone of the distal phalange of a finger or toe proximal
to the visible base of the nail will be considered as equivalent to the loss of one-half
(½) of such finger of toe.
- Amputation through the forearm at a point so distal to the elbow as to permit
satisfactory use of a prosthetic appliance with retention of full natural elbow function
shall be considered amputation of the hand. Otherwise, it shall be considered amputation
of the arm.
- Amputation through the lower leg at a point so distal to the knee as to permit
satisfactory use of a prosthetic appliance with retention of full natural knee function
shall be considered amputation of the foot. Otherwise, it shall be considered amputation
of the leg.
Rule 406
Discount Table to Be Used in Determining Commuted Values
The Industrial Commission in its discretion will designate the interest rate and
methods of computation to be used in arriving at the commuted value of unaccrued
compensation payments.
Rule 407
Fees for Medical Compensation
- Subject to the provisions of N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-25.3,
"Preauthorization," the Industrial Commission shall adopt and publish a Fee
Schedule, pursuant to the provisions of N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-26(a), fixing maximum fees, except for hospital fees pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-26(b), which may be charged for medical, surgical, nursing, dental, and
rehabilitative services, and medicines, sick travel, and other treatment, including
medical and surgical supplies, original artificial members as may reasonably be necessary
at the end of the healing period and the replacement of such artificial members when
reasonably necessitated by ordinary use or medical circumstances. The fees prescribed in
the applicable published Fee Schedule shall govern and apply in all cases. However, in
special hardship cases where sufficient reason is demonstrated to the Industrial
Commission, fees in excess of those so published may be allowed. Persons who disagree with
the allowance of such fees in any case may make application for and obtain a full review
of the matter before the Industrial Commission as in all other cases provided. Copies of
this published Fee Schedule may be obtained from the Industrial Commissions
authorized vendor.
- A provider of medical compensation shall submit its statement for services within 75
days of the rendition of the service or if treatment is longer, within 30 days after the
end of the month during which multiple treatments were provided, or within such other
reasonable period of time as allowed by the Industrial Commission. However, in cases where
liability is initially denied but subsequently admitted or determined by the Industrial
Commission, the time for submission of medical bills shall run from the time the health
care provider received notice of the admission or determination of liability. Within 30
days of receipt of the statement, the employer, or carrier, or managed care organization,
or administrator on its behalf, shall pay or submit the statement to the Industrial
Commission for approval or send the provider written objections to the statement. If an
employer, carrier/ administrator or managed care organization disputes a portion of the
providers bill, it shall pay the uncontested portion of the bill and shall resolve
disputes regarding the balance of the charges through its contractual arrangement or
through the Industrial Commission. If any bill for medical compensation services is not
paid within 60 days after it has been approved by the Industrial Commission and returned
to the responsible party, or, when the employee is receiving treatment through a managed
care organization, within 60 days after the bill has been properly submitted to an insurer
or managed care organization, there shall be added to such unpaid bill an amount equal to
10%, which shall be paid at the same time as, but in addition to, such bill, unless late
payment is excused by the Industrial Commission. When the 10% addition to the bill is
uncontested, payment shall be made to the provider without notifying or seeking approval
from the Industrial Commission. When the 10% addition to the bill is contested, any party
may request a hearing by the Industrial Commission pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-83,
and N.C. Gen. Stat.
§97-84.
- When the responsible party seeks an audit of hospital charges, and has paid the hospital
charges in full, the payee hospital, upon request, shall provide all reasonable access and
copies of appropriate records, without charge or fee, to the person(s) chosen by the payor
to review and audit the records.
- The responsible employer or carrier/administrator shall pay the statements of medical
compensation providers to whom the employee has been referred by the authorized treating
physician, unless said physician has been requested to obtain authorization for referrals
or tests; provided, that compliance with such request does not unreasonably delay the
treatment or service to be rendered to the employee.
- It is the responsibility of the carrier, self-insured employer, group insured as
certified by the North Carolina Department of Insurance, and statutory self-insured (state
agency or political subdivision) to submit on a yearly basis a Form 51, Consolidated Fiscal
Annual Report of "Medical Only" and "Lost Time" Cases.
- Employees shall be entitled to reimbursement for sick travel when the travel is
medically necessary and the mileage is 20 or more miles, round trip, at a rate to be
established periodically by the Industrial Commission in its Minutes. Employees shall be
entitled to lodging and meal expenses, at a rate to be periodically established by the
Industrial Commission in its Minutes, when it is medically necessary that the employee
stay overnight at a location away from the employees usual place of residence. An
employee shall be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of parking or a vehicle for
hire, when the costs are medically necessary, at the actual costs of the expenses, unless
the Industrial Commission determines the expenses were not reasonable.
- Any employer/carrier/administrator denying a claim in which medical care has previously
been authorized shall be responsible for all costs incurred prior to the date notice of
denial is provided to each health care provider to whom authorization has been previously
given.
Rule 408
Additional Medical Compensation
- The Industrial Commission may enter an order as contemplated by N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-25.1
providing for additional medical compensation on its own motion or pursuant to a
stipulation of the parties or by approval of an agreement of the parties for additional
medical compensation reflected in a Form 21 or a Form 26.
- If the parties have not reached an agreement regarding additional medical compensation,
an employee may file a claim with the Industrial Commission for an order pursuant to the
terms of N.C. Gen.
Stat. §97-25.1, for payment of additional medical compensation within two years of
the date of the last payment of medical or indemnity compensation, whichever shall last
occur. The claim may be made on a Form 18M or by written
request to the Industrial Commission. The filing of this claim tolls the time limit
contained in this paragraph and in N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-25.1.
The original and one copy of the claim must be filed with the Industrial Commissions
Office of the Executive Secretary, one copy must be provided to the employer or
carrier/administrator, and one copy must be provided to the attorney of record, if any.
- Upon receipt of the claim, the Industrial Commission will notify the employer or
carrier/administrator that the claim has been received by providing a copy of a Form 18M or a written claim.
The employer or carrier/administrator shall, within 30 days, send to the Industrial
Commission and to the employee and the employees attorney of record, if any, a
written statement as to whether the employees request is accepted or denied. If the
request is denied, the employer or carrier/administrator shall state in writing the
grounds for the denial and shall attach any supporting documentation to the statement of
denial.
- In cases where the employees right to additional medical compensation is
contested, the Form 18M,
Request for Additional Medical Compensation, shall be treated as a Motion to the Executive
Secretary for future medical compensation. Defendants shall have 30 days to respond. An
administrative ruling shall thereafter be made subject to the right of either party to
appeal such administrative decision by filing a Form 33, Request for Hearing,
pursuant to the 15 day time limitation contained in Rule 703. An appeal
of the Administrative Decision shall have the effect of staying the decision, provided
that the stay may be dissolved in the discretion of the Commission for good cause shown.
- This Rule applies to injuries by accident occurring on or after July 5, 1994.
Rule 409
Claims for Death Benefits
- Report of Fatalities
- Any person claiming entitlement to death benefits under the Act shall give written
notice to the employer of the occurrence of death allegedly arising out of and in the
course of employment in accordance with N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-22.
- An employer shall notify the Commission of the occurrence of a death resulting
from an injury or occupational disease allegedly arising out of and in the
course of employment by timely filing a Form 19 within five days of
knowledge thereof. In addition, an employer or carrier/administrator shall file
with the Industrial Commission a Form 29, "Supplementary
Report for Fatal Accidents," within 45 days of knowledge of a death or
allegation of death resulting from an injury or occupational disease arising out of and in
the course of employment.
- Identifying Beneficiaries
- An employer or carrier/administrator shall make a good faith effort to discover the
names and addresses of decedents beneficiaries under N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-38
and identify them on the Form 29.
- In all cases involving minors or incompetents who are potential beneficiaries, a
guardian ad litem shall be appointed pursuant to Rule 604.
- If an issue exists as to whether a person is a beneficiary under N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-38,
the employer or carrier/administrator and/or any person asserting a claim for benefits may
file a Form 33 Request for
Hearing for a determination by a Deputy Commissioner.
- Liability Accepted by Employer
- If the employer or carrier/administrator accepts liability for a claim involving an
employees death and there are no apparent issues necessitating a hearing for
determination of beneficiaries and/or their respective rights, the parties shall submit
an Agreement for Compensation for Death executed by all interested parties or
their representatives on Industrial Commission Form 30. All agreements must
be submitted to the Industrial Commission on a Form 30 as set forth in Rule 501(4), (5) and (6).
- Said agreement shall be submitted along with all relevant supporting documents,
including death certificate of the employee, any relevant marriage certificate and birth
certificates for any dependents.
- Liability Denied by Employer
- If the employer or carrier/administrator denies liability for a claim involving an
employees death, the employer or carrier/administrator shall send a letter of denial
to all potential beneficiaries, their attorneys of record, if any, all heath care
providers that have submitted bills to the employer or carrier/administrator, and the
Industrial Commission. The denial letter shall specifically state the reasons for the
denial and shall further advise of a right to hearing.
- Any potential beneficiary or the employer or carrier/administrator may request a hearing
as provided in Rule 602.
- Payment of Death Benefits
- Upon approval of the Industrial Commission of a Form 30, Agreement for
Compensation for Death, or the issuance of a final order of the Industrial Commission
directing payment of death benefits pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-38,
payment may be made by the employer or carrier/administrator directly to the
beneficiaries, with the following exceptions: (1) any
applicable award of attorney fees shall be paid directly to the attorney; and (2) benefits
due to a minor or incompetent.
- (i) Subject to the discretion of the Industrial Commission, any benefits due to a minor
pursuant to N.C. Gen.
Stat. §97-38 may be paid directly to the parent as natural guardian of the minor for
the use and benefit of the minor if the minor remains in the physical custody of the
parent as natural guardian. If the minor is not in the physical custody of the parent as
natural guardian, the Industrial Commission may order that payment be made through some
other proper person appointed by a court of competent jurisdiction.
(ii) In order to protect the interests of an incompetent beneficiary, the Industrial
Commission in its discretion may order that benefits be paid to the beneficiarys
duly appointed general guardian for the beneficiarys exclusive use and benefit, or
to the Clerk of Court in the county in which he resides for the beneficiarys
exclusive use and benefit as determined by the Clerk of Court.
(iii) Upon a change in circumstances, any interested party may request that the
Industrial Commission amend the terms of any award with respect to a minor or incompetent
to direct payment to another party on behalf of the minor or incompetent. When a
beneficiary reaches the age of 18, any remaining benefits shall be paid directly to
the beneficiary.
- In the case of commuted benefits, only those sums which have not accrued at the time of
the entry of the Order are subject to commutation.
- Procedure for Award of Death Benefits Based on Stipulated Facts
- Where the parties seek a written opinion and award from the Commission regarding the
payment of death benefits in uncontested cases in lieu of presenting testimony at a
hearing before a Deputy Commissioner, the parties may make application to the Commission
for a written opinion by filing a written request with the Dockets Director.
- The parties shall file the following information by joint stipulation, affidavit or
certified document:
- a stipulation regarding all jurisdictional matters;
- the decedents name, social security number, employer, insurance carrier or
servicing agent, and the date of the injury giving rise to this claim;
- a Form 22 or stipulation
as to average weekly wage;
- any affidavits regarding dependents;
- the death certificate;
- I.C. Form 29;
- Guardian ad Litem forms, if any beneficiary is a minor or incompetent;
- proof of beneficiary status, such as marriage license, birth certificate, or divorce
decree;
- medical records, if any;
- a statement of payment of medical expenses incurred, if any; and
- a funeral bill or stipulation as to payment of the funeral benefit.
- Upon receipt of said information and notice to potential beneficiaries, the Deputy
Commissioner shall render a written Opinion and Award.
- Any attorney seeking fees for the representation of an uncontested claim shall file an
affidavit or itemized statement in support of an award of attorney fees.
ARTICLE V. AGREEMENTS
Rule 501
Agreements for Payment of Compensation
-
To facilitate the prompt payment of compensation
within the time prescribed in
N.C. Gen.
Stat. §97-18, the Industrial Commission will accept memoranda of agreements
on Industrial Commission forms.
- No agreement for permanent disability will be approved until the material medical and vocational records known to exist in the case have been filed with the
Industrial Commission. When requested by the Industrial Commission, the
parties shall file any additional documentation necessary to determine whether
the employee is receiving the disability compensation to which he or she is
entitled and that an employee qualifying for disability compensation under both
N.C. Gen.
Stat. §97-29 or
§97-30
and
N.C. Gen.
Stat. §97-31 has the benefit of the more favorable remedy.
-
All memoranda of agreements must be submitted to the Industrial Commission in
triplicate on Industrial Commission forms, as specified in paragraph 6 below.
Agreements in proper form and conforming to the provisions of the Workers’
Compensation Act will be approved by the Industrial Commission and a copy
returned to the employer or carrier/administrator and a copy sent to the
employee, unless amended by award, in which event a copy of the award will be
returned with the agreement.
- The employer or carrier/administrator, or the attorney of record, if any, shall
provide the employee and the employee’s attorney of record, if any, a copy of a
Form 21,
Form 26,
Form 26D, and
Form 30, when
the employee signs said forms, and the employer or carrier/administrator will
send a copy of a
Form 28B to the employee and the employee’s attorney of record, if any,
within 16 days after the last payment of compensation for either temporary or
permanent disability, pursuant to
N.C. Gen.
Stat. §97-18.
- All memoranda of agreements
for cases which are currently calendared for hearing before a Commissioner
or Deputy Commissioner shall be sent directly to that Commissioner or Deputy
Commissioner. Before
a case is calendared, or once a case has been continued, or removed, or after
the filing of an Opinion and Award, all memoranda of agreements shall be
directed to the Claims Section of the Industrial
Commission.
-
After the employer or carrier/administrator has received a memorandum of
agreement which has been signed by the employee and employee’s attorney of
record, if any, it shall have 20 days within which to submit the memorandum of
agreement to the Industrial Commission for review and approval or within which
to show good cause for not submitting the memorandum of agreement signed only by
the employee; provided, however, that for good cause shown, the 20 day period
may be extended.
Rule 502
Compromise Settlement Agreements
- All compromise settlement agreements must be submitted to the Industrial Commission for
approval. Only those agreements deemed fair and just and in the best interest of all
parties will be approved.
- No compromise agreement will be approved unless it contains the following language or
its equivalent:
- Where liability is admitted, that the employer or carrier/ administrator undertakes to
pay all medical expenses to the date of the agreement.
- Where liability is denied, that the employer or carrier/ administrator undertakes to pay
all unpaid medical expenses to the date of the agreement. However, this requirement may be
waived in the discretion of the Industrial Commission. When submitting an agreement for
approval, the employee or employees attorney, if any, shall advise the Commission in
writing of the amount of the unpaid medical expenses.
- That the employee knowingly and intentionally waives the right to further benefits under
the Workers Compensation Act for the injury which is the subject of this agreement.
- That the employer or carrier/administrator will pay all costs incurred.
- That no rights other than those arising under the provisions of the Workers
Compensation Act are compromised or released.
- That the employee has, or has not, returned to a job or position at the same or a
greater average weekly wage as was being earned prior to the injury or occupational
disease.
- Where the employee has not returned to a job or position at the same or a greater wage
as was being earned prior to the injury or occupational disease, that the employee has, or
has not, returned to some other job or position, and, if so, the description of the
particular job or position, the name of the employer and the average weekly wage earned.
This subsection of the Rule shall not apply where the employee is represented by counsel
or, even if the employee is not represented by counsel, where the employee certifies that
partial wage loss due to an injury or occupational disease is not being claimed.
- Where the employee has not returned to a job or position at the same or a greater
average weekly wage as was being earned prior to the injury or occupational disease, the
agreement shall summarize the employees age, educational level, past vocational
training, past work experience, and any impairment, emotional, mental or physical, which
predates the current injury or occupational disease. The parties will be relieved of this
duty only upon a showing that providing such information creates an unreasonable burden
upon them. This subsection of the Rule shall not apply where employee is represented by
counsel or, even if the employee is not represented by counsel, where the employee
certifies that total wage loss due to an injury or occupational disease is not being
claimed.
- No compromise agreement will be considered unless the following additional requirements
are met:
- The material medical, vocational, and rehabilitation reports known to exist, including but not
limited to those pertinent to the employees future earning capacity, must be
submitted with the agreement to the Industrial Commission by the employer, the
carrier/administrator, or the attorney for the employer.
- The parties and all attorneys of record must have signed the agreement.
- The settlement agreement must contain a list of all
of the known medical expenses of the employee related to the injury to the date
of the settlement agreement, including medical expenses that the employer or
insurance carrier disputes, when the employer or carrier has not agreed to pay
all medical expenses of the employee related to the injury up to the date of the
settlement agreement.
-
If there are unpaid medical expenses which the employer or insurance carrier
agree to pay under the settlement agreement, the agreement must contain a list
of these unpaid medical expenses, if known, that will be paid by the employer or
insurance carrier.
- The settlement agreement must contain a finding
that the positions of the parties to the agreement are reasonable as to the
payment of medical expenses.
- When a settlement has been reached, the written agreement must be submitted to the
Industrial Commission within a reasonable time. All compromise settlement agreements which
are currently calendared for hearing before a Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner shall be
sent directly to that Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner at the Industrial Commission.
Before a case is calendared, or once a case has been continued, or removed, or after the
filing of an Opinion and Award, all compromise settlement agreements shall be directed to
the Executive Secretary of the Industrial Commission.
- Once a compromise settlement agreement has been approved by the Industrial Commission,
the employer or carrier/administrator shall furnish an executed copy of said agreement to
the employee or his attorney of record, if any.
- An attorney seeking fees in connection with a Compromise Settlement Agreement shall
submit to the Commission a copy of the fee agreement with the client.
Rule 503
Approval of Agreement Constitutes Award
An agreement for the payment of compensation approved by the Industrial Commission
shall thereupon become an award of the Industrial Commission and shall be a part of the
record in any further proceedings in the matter.
ARTICLE VI. CONTESTED CASES
Rule 601
Employer Obligations Upon Notice, Sanctions, and Denial of Liability
-
The employer or its insurance carrier shall
promptly investigate each injury reported or known to the employer and at the
earliest practicable time shall admit or deny the employee’s right to
compensation or commence payment of compensation as provided in
N.C. Gen.
Stat. §97-18(b), (c), or (d).
-
When an employee files a claim for compensation
with the Commission, the Commission may order reasonable sanctions against the
employer or its insurance carrier which does not, within 30 days following
notice from the Commission of the filing of the claim, or 90 days when a disease
is alleged to be from exposure to chemicals, fumes, or other materials or
substances in the workplace, or within such reasonable additional time as the
Commission may allow, do one of the following:
-
Notify the Commission and the employee in writing
that it is admitting the employee’s right to compensation and, if applicable,
satisfy the requirements for payment of compensation under
N.C. Gen.
Stat §97-18(b).
-
Notify the Commission and the employee that it
denies the employee’s right to compensation consistent with
N.C. Gen.
Stat §97-18(c).
-
Initiate payments without prejudice and without
liability and satisfy the requirements of
N.C. Gen.
Stat §97-18(d).
For purposes of this Rule, reasonable sanctions shall
not prohibit the employer or its insurance carrier from contesting the
compensability of and its liability for the claim.
Requests for extensions of time to comply with this
rule may be addressed to the Executive Secretary.
-
If the employer or insurance carrier denies
liability in any case, a
detailed statement of the basis of denial must be set forth in a letter of denial or
Form 61, which shall be sent
to the plaintiff or his attorney of record, if any, all known health care providers which
have submitted bills to the employer/carrier, and the Industrial Commission.
The detailed statement of the basis of denial shall set forth a statement of the facts,
as alleged by the employer, concerning the injury or any other matter in dispute; a
statement identifying the source, by name or date and type of document, of the facts
alleged by the employer; and a statement explaining why the facts, as alleged by the
employer, do not entitle the employee to workers compensation benefits.
Rule 602
Request for Hearing
Contested claims shall be set on the hearing docket only upon the written request of
one of the parties, unless the Industrial Commission orders on its own motion, a hearing
or rehearing of the case in dispute. The request for hearing shall contain
the following:
- The basis of the disagreement between the parties, including a statement of the specific
issues raised by the requesting party.
- The date of the injury.
- The part of the body injured.
- The city and county where the injury occurred.
- The names and addresses of all doctors and other expert witnesses whose testimony is
needed by the requesting party.
- The names of all lay witnesses to be called to testify for the requesting party.
- An estimate of the time required for the hearing of the case.
- The telephone number(s) and address(es) of the party(ies) requesting the hearing.
A Form 33, Request for
Hearing, completed in full, shall constitute compliance with this Rule. A copy of the
Request for Hearing shall be forwarded to the self-insured employer or insurance carrier
if not represented, or to the defendants attorney, if one has been retained.
Rule 603
Response to Request for Hearing
No later than 45 days from receipt of the Request for Hearing, the self-insured
employer, insurance carrier, or counsel for the defendant(s) shall file with the
Industrial Commission a response to the Request for Hearing.
This response shall contain the following:
- The basis of the disagreement between the parties, including a statement of the specific
issues raised by the plaintiff which are conceded and the specific issues raised by the
plaintiff which are denied.
- The date of the injury, if it is contended to be different than that alleged by the
plaintiff.
- The part of the body injured, if it is contended to be different than that alleged by
the plaintiff.
- The city and county where the injury occurred, if they are contented to be different
than that alleged by the plaintiff.
- The names and addresses of all doctors and other expert witnesses whose testimony is
needed by the defendant(s).
- The names of all lay witnesses known by the defendant(s) whose testimony is to be
taken.
- An estimate of the time required for the hearing of the case.
- The telephone number(s) and address(es) of the party(ies) responding to the Request for
Hearing.
Utilization of a Form 33R,
Response to Request for Hearing, which is completed in full, shall be the sole means of
compliance with this Rule. A copy of the Response to Request for Hearing shall be
forwarded to all opposing parties or their attorneys, if such have been retained. In the
event of a request for hearing by a defendant, the employee shall not be required to
respond. Extensions of time within which to file a response shall be granted for good
cause shown.
Rule 604
Appointment of Guardian Ad Litem
- In all cases where it is proposed that minors or incompetents shall sue by their
guardian ad litem, the Industrial Commission shall appoint such guardian ad
litem upon the written application of a reputable person closely connected with such
minor or incompetent; but if such person will not apply, then, upon the application of
some reputable citizen; and the Industrial Commission shall make such appointment only
after due inquiry as to the fitness of the person to be appointed.
- In no event, however, shall any compensation be paid directly to the guardian ad
litem. Rather, compensation payable to a minor or incompetent shall be paid as
provided in N.C. Gen.
Stat. §97-48 and N.C.
Gen. Stat. §97-49. The use of the word "guardian" in N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-49
does not mean a guardian ad litem.
Rule 605
Discovery
In addition to depositions and production of books and records provided for in N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-80,
parties may obtain discovery by the use of interrogatories as follows:
- Any party may serve upon any other parties written interrogatories, up to 30 in number,
including subparts thereof, to be answered by the party served or, if the party served is
a public or private corporation or a partnership or association or governmental agency, by
any officer or agent, who shall furnish such information as is available from the party
interrogated.
Interrogatories may, without leave of the Industrial Commission, be served upon any
party after the filing of a Form
18, Form 18B, or Form 33, or after approval of
Form 21.
Each interrogatory shall be answered separately and fully in writing under oath, unless
it is objected to, in which event the reasons for objection shall be stated in lieu of an
answer. The answers are to be signed by the person making them and the objections signed
by the party making them. The party on whom the interrogatories have been served shall
serve a copy of the answers, and objections, if any, within 30 days after service of the
interrogatories. The parties may stipulate to an extension of time to respond to the
interrogatories. A motion to extend the time to respond shall represent that an attempt to
reach agreement with the opposing party to informally extend the time for response has
been unsuccessful and the opposing parties position or that there has been a
reasonable attempt to contact the opposing party to ascertain its position.
If there is an objection to or other failure to answer an interrogatory, the party
submitting the interrogatories may move the Industrial Commission for an order compelling
answer. If the Industrial Commission orders answer to an interrogatory within a time
certain and no answer is made or the objection is still lodged, the Industrial Commission
may issue an order with appropriate sanctions, including but not limited to the sanctions
specified in Rule 37
of the North Carolina Rules of Civil Procedure.
- Interrogatories may relate to matters which are not privileged which are relevant to an
issue presently in dispute or which the requesting party reasonably believes may later be
disputed. Signature of a party or attorney serving interrogatories
constitutes a certificate by such person that he or she has personally read each of the
interrogatories, that no such interrogatory will oppress a party or cause any unnecessary
expense or delay, that the information requested is not known or equally available to the
requesting party and that the interrogatory relates to an issue presently in dispute or
which the requesting party reasonably believes may later be in dispute. A party may serve
an interrogatory, however, to obtain verification of facts relating to an issue presently
in dispute. Answers to interrogatories may be used to the extent permitted
by the rules of evidence.
- Additional methods of discovery as provided by the North Carolina Rules of Civil
Procedure may be used only upon motion and approval by the Industrial Commission or by
agreement of the parties.
- Notices of depositions, discovery requests and responses pertinent to a pending motion,
responses to discovery following a motion or order to compel, and post-hearing discovery
requests and responses shall be filed with the Commission, as well as served on the
opposing party. Otherwise, discovery requests and responses, including interrogatories and
requests for production of documents, shall not be filed with the Commission.
- Sanctions may be imposed under this Rule for failure to comply with a Commission order
compelling discovery. A motion by a party or its attorney to compel discovery under this
Rule and Rule 607 shall represent that informal means of resolving the
discovery dispute have been attempted in good faith and state briefly the opposing
parties position or that there has been a reasonable attempt to contact the opposing
party and ascertain its position.
Rule 606
Discovery Post Hearing
Discovery may not be conducted after the initial hearing on the merits of a case unless
allowed by order of a Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner.
Rule 607
Discovery of Records and Reports
Upon written request, any party shall furnish, without cost, the requesting party a
copy of any and all medical, vocational and rehabilitation reports, employment records,
Industrial Commission forms, and written communications with medical providers in
its possession, within 30 days of the request, unless objection is made within that time
period. This obligation exists whether or not a request for hearing has been filed. This
obligation is a continuing one, and any such reports and records which come into the
possession of a party after receipt of a request pursuant to this Rule shall be provided
to the requesting party within 15 days from its receipt of these reports and records.
Upon receipt of a request, an insurer or administrator for an employers
workers compensation program shall inquire of the employer concerning the existence
of records encompassed by the request.
Rule 608
Statement About Incident Leading to Claim
- At the outset of taking a statement, the employer or his agent shall advise the employee
that the statement is being taken to be used in part to determine whether the claim will
be paid or denied. Any plaintiff who gives his employer, or its carrier, or any agent
either a written or recorded statement of the facts and circumstances surrounding his
injury shall be furnished a copy of such statement within 45 days after request. Further,
any plaintiff who shall give a written or recorded statement of the facts and
circumstances surrounding his injury shall, without request, be furnished a copy no less
than 45 days from the filing of a Form 33 Request for Hearing.
Such copy shall be furnished at the expense of the person, firm or corporation at whose
direction the statement was taken.
- If any person, firm or corporation fails to comply with this rule, then an order may be
entered by a Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner prohibiting that person, firm or
corporation, or its representative, from introducing the statement into evidence or using
any part of it.
Rule 609
Motions Practice in Contested Cases
- Motions brought before the Commission shall be addressed as follows:
- All motions in cases which are currently calendared for hearing before the Full Commission
or Deputy Commissioner shall be sent directly to the Chair of the Full Commission panel
or Deputy Commissioner before whom the case is pending.
- Motions filed before a case is calendared before a Deputy Commissioner, or
once a case has been continued, or removed from a Deputy Commissioner calendar, or after
the filing of an Opinion and Award when the time for taking appeal has run, shall be
directed to the Executive Secretary of the Industrial Commission. Motions to reconsider or
amend an Opinion and Award, made prior to giving notice of appeal to the Full Commission,
shall be directed to the Deputy Commissioner who authored the Opinion and Award.
- Motions filed after notice of appeal to the Full Commission has been given but prior to
the calendaring of the case shall be directed to the Chair of the Industrial Commission.
- If a case has been continued from the Full Commission hearing docket, motions shall be
directed to the Chair of the panel of Commissioners who ordered the continuance.
- Motions filed after the filing of an Opinion and Award by the Full Commission but prior
to giving notice of appeal to the Court of Appeals shall be directed to the Commissioner
who authored the Opinion and Award.
- A motion shall state with particularity the grounds on which it is based, the relief
sought, and a brief statement of the opposing partys position, if known. Service
shall be made on all opposing attorneys of record, or on all opposing parties, if not
represented.
- Motions to continue or remove a case from the hearing calendar on which the case is set
must be made well in advance of the scheduled hearing and may be made in written or oral
form. In all cases the moving party must provide just cause for the motion and state
that the other parties have been advised of the motion and relate the position, if known,
of the other parties regarding the motion. Oral motions must be followed with a written
confirmation from the moving party.
- The responding party to a motion shall have 10 days after a motion is
served during which to file and serve copies of response in opposition to the motion. The
Industrial Commission may shorten or extend the time for responding to any motion.
- Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 4 above, a motion may be
acted upon at any time by the Commission, despite the absence of notice to all parties,
and without awaiting a response thereto. A party who has not received actual notice of
such a motion or who has not filed a response at the time such action is taken and who is
adversely affected by the action may request that it be reconsidered,
vacated, or modified. Motions will be determined without oral argument, unless the
Industrial Commission orders otherwise.
- In all cases where correspondence relative to a case before the Industrial Commission is
sent to the Industrial Commission, copies of such correspondence shall be
contemporaneously sent by the same method of transmission to the opposing party or, if
represented, to opposing counsel. Written communications, whether addressed
directly to the Commission or copied to the Commission, may not be used as an opportunity
to introduce new evidence or to argue the merits of the case, with the exception of the
following instances:
- Written communications, such as a proposed order or legal memorandum, prepared pursuant
to the Commissions instructions;
- Written communications relative to emergencies, changed circumstances, or scheduling
matters that may affect the procedural status of a case such as a request for a
continuance due to the health of a litigant or an attorney;
- Written communications sent to the tribunal with the consent of the opposing lawyer or
opposing party if unrepresented; and
- Any other communication permitted by law or the rules or procedures of the Commission.
At no time may written communications, whether addressed directly to the Commission or
copied to the Commission, be used as an opportunity to cast the opposing party or counsel
in a bad light.
- All motions made before the Industrial Commission must include a proposed Order to be
considered by the Industrial Commission.
- Except as otherwise expressly provided by statute, rule, or by order of the Commission,
in computing any period of time prescribed or allowed by the Commission Rules, by order of
the Commission, or by any applicable statute, the day of the act, event, or default after
which the designated period of time begins to run is not to be included. The last day of
the period so computed is to be included, unless it is a Saturday, Sunday, or a legal
holiday, in which event the period runs until the end of the next day which is not a
Saturday, Sunday or a legal holiday. When the period of time prescribed or allowed is less
than seven days, intermediate Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays shall be excluded in the
computation. Whenever a party has the right to do some act or take some proceedings within
a prescribed period after the service of any document, three days shall be added to the
prescribed period.
Rule 610
Pre-Trial Conference and Pre-Trial Order
- A Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner may order the parties to appear at a pre-trial
conference to determine specific matters. This conference may be conducted at such place
and by such method as the Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner deems appropriate, including
conference telephone calls.
- Any party may request a pre-trial conference when that party deems that such a
conference would aid in settling the case or resolving some issues prior to trial.
Requests for such pre-trial conferences shall be directed to the Deputy Commissioner
before whom the claim has been calendared, or to the Team Coordinator for the geographical
area, if any.
- A Commissioner or a Deputy Commissioner may issue a Pre-Trial Order
requiring the parties to submit a Pre-trial Agreement. The parties shall have 15 days
following the hearing within which to schedule the taking of medical depositions unless
otherwise extended by the Commission. Such Agreement shall be prepared in a form which
substantially complies with the Order on Final Pre-Trial Conference adopted in the North
Carolina Rules of Practice for the Superior and District Courts. Should the parties fail
to comply with a Pre-Trial Order, the Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner
may remove the case from the hearing docket. Should the parties thereafter comply with the
Pre-Trial Order after the removal of the case, the Pre-Trial Agreement must be directed to
the Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner who removed the case from the docket; and the
Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner will order the case returned to the hearing docket as
if a Request for Hearing had been filed on the date of the Order to return the case to the
hearing docket. No new Form 33
Request for Hearing is required.
Rule 611
Hearings Before the Industrial Commission
- The Industrial Commission may on its own motion order a hearing or rehearing of any case
in dispute.
- The Industrial Commission shall set a contested case for hearing in a location deemed
convenient to witnesses and the Industrial Commission, and conducive to an early and just
resolution of disputed issues.
- In setting contested cases for hearing, cases in which the payment of workers
compensation benefits is at issue shall take precedence over those cases in which the
payment of workers compensation benefits is not at issue.
- The Industrial Commission will give reasonable notice of hearings in every case.
Postponement or continuance of a duly scheduled hearing will rest entirely in the
discretion of a Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner. Where a party has not notified the
Industrial Commission of the attorney representing the party prior to the mailing of
calendars for hearing, notice to that party shall constitute notice to the partys
attorney.
- The only parts of the Industrial Commission file in a contested case which are a part of
the record on which a decision will be rendered are prior Opinion and Awards, form
agreements, awards, and orders of the Industrial Commission; provided, however, that if
provisions of the Workers Compensation Act designate other documents as part of the
record, such documents shall also be a part of the record. Any other documents which the
parties wish to have included in the record must be introduced and received into evidence.
- Hearing costs shall be assessed in each case set for hearing, including those cases
which are settled after being calendared and notices mailed, and shall be payable upon
receipt of a statement from the Industrial Commission.
- In the event of inclement weather or natural disaster, hearings shall be cancelled if
the proceedings in the General Court of Justice in the county in which the hearings are
set are cancelled.
Rule 612
Depositions and Additional Hearings
- When additional testimony is necessary to the disposition of a case, a Commissioner or
Deputy Commissioner may order the deposition of witnesses to be taken on or before a day
certain not to exceed 60 days from the date of the ruling; provided, the time allowed
may be enlarged for good cause shown. The costs of such depositions shall be borne
by defendants for those medical witnesses who examined plaintiff at defendants
expense, in those instances in which defendants are requesting the depositions, and in any
other case which, in the discretion of the Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner, it is
deemed appropriate.
- In cases where a party, or an attorney for either party, refuses to stipulate medical
reports and the case must be reset or depositions ordered for testimony of medical
witnesses, a Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner may in his discretion assess the costs of
such hearing or depositions, including reasonable attorney fees, against the party who
refused the stipulation.
- Except under unusual circumstances, all lay evidence must be offered at the initial
hearing. Lay evidence can only be offered after the initial hearing by order of a
Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner. The costs of obtaining lay testimony by deposition
shall be borne by the party making the request unless otherwise ordered by the Commission.
Rule 613
Dismissals and Removals
- Dismissals
- No claim filed under the Workers Compensation Act shall be dismissed without
prejudice at plaintiffs instance except upon order of the Industrial Commission and
upon such terms and conditions as justice requires; provided, however, that no voluntary
dismissal shall be granted after the record in a case is closed.
- Unless otherwise ordered by the Industrial Commission, a plaintiff shall have one year
from the date of the Order of Voluntary Dismissal to refile his claim.
- Upon proper notice and an opportunity to be heard, any claim may be dismissed with or
without prejudice by the Industrial Commission on its own motion or by motion of any party
for failure to prosecute or to comply with these Rules or any Order of the Commission.
- Removals
- A claim may be removed from the hearing docket by motion of the party requesting the
hearing or by the Industrial Commission upon its own motion.
- A removed case may be reinstated by motion of either party; provided that when the
issues have materially changed since the Order of Removal or where the motion to reinstate
is filed more than one year after the Order of Removal, a Form 33 Request for Hearing
will be required.
- When a plaintiff has not requested a hearing within two years of the filing of an Order
of Removal requested by the plaintiff or necessitated by the plaintiffs conduct, and
not pursued the claim, upon proper notice and an opportunity to be heard,
any claim may be dismissed with prejudice by the Industrial Commission on its own motion
or by motion of any party.
Rule 614
Attorneys Retained for Proceedings
- Any attorney who is retained by a party in a proceeding before the
Industrial Commission shall immediately file a notice of appearance with the Industrial
Commission. A copy of this notice shall be served on all other counsel and on all
unrepresented parties. Thereafter, all notices required to be served on a party shall be
served upon the attorney. No direct contact or communication concerning contested matters
may be made with a represented party by the opposing party or any person on
its behalf, without the attorneys permission except as permitted by
law or Industrial Commission Rules.
- Any attorney who wishes to withdraw from representation in a proceeding before the
Industrial Commission shall file with the Industrial Commission, in writing:
- A Motion to Withdraw which shall contain a statement of reasons for the request and that
the request has been served on the client.
- A Motion to Withdraw before an award is made shall state whether the withdrawing
attorney requests an attorney fee from the represented party once an award of compensation
is made or approved.
- An attorney may withdraw from representation only by written order of the
Industrial Commission. The issuance of an award of the Industrial Commission does not
release an attorney as the attorney of record.
Rule 615
Disqualification of a Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner
In their discretion, Commissioners or Deputy Commissioners may recuse themselves from
the hearing of any case before the Industrial Commission. For good cause shown, a majority
of the Full Commission may remove a Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner from hearing a
case.
Rule 616
Foreign Language Interpreters
- Services of Foreign Language Interpreters Required.
When a person who does not speak or understand the English language is called to
testify in a hearing, other than in an informal hearing conducted pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-18.1,
the person, whether a party or a witness, shall be assisted by a qualified foreign
language interpreter.
- Qualifications of Interpreters.
To qualify as a foreign language interpreter, a person must possess sufficient
experience and education, or a combination of experience and education, speaking and
understanding English and the foreign language to be interpreted, to qualify as an expert
witness pursuant to N.C.
Gen. Stat. §1C-1, Rule 702. A person qualified as an interpreter under this Rule
shall not be interested in the claim and must make a declaration under oath or affirmation
to interpret accurately, truthfully and without any additions or deletions, all questions
propounded to the witness and all responses thereto.
- Notice to Industrial Commission and Opposing Party of Need for
Interpreter.
Any party who is unable to speak or understand English, or who intends to call as a
witness a person who is unable to speak or understand English, shall so notify the
Industrial Commission and the opposing party, in writing, not less than 21 days prior to
the date of the hearing. The notice shall state with specificity the language(s) that must
be interpreted for the Commission.
- Designation of Interpreter.
Upon receiving or giving the notice required in paragraph (3) of this
Rule, the employer or insurer shall retain a qualified, disinterested interpreter, either
agreed upon by the parties or approved by the Industrial Commission, to
appear at the hearing and interpret the testimony of all persons for whom the notice in
paragraph (3) has been given or received.
- Interpreter Fees.
The interpreters fee shall constitute a cost as contemplated by N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-80.
A qualified interpreter who interprets testimony for the Industrial Commission shall be
entitled to payment of the fee agreed upon by the interpreter and employer or insurer that
retained the interpreter. Except in cases where a claim for compensation has been
prosecuted without reasonable ground, the fee agreed upon by the interpreter and employer
or insurer shall be paid by the employer or insurer. Where it is ultimately determined by
the Commission that the request for an interpreter was unfounded, attendant costs may be
assessed against the movant.
ARTICLE VII. APPEALS
Rule 701
Appeal to the Full Commission
- A letter expressing an intent to appeal shall be considered notice of appeal to the Full
Commission within the meaning of N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-85,
provided that it clearly specifies the Order or Opinion and Award from which appeal is
taken.
- After receipt of notice of appeal, the Industrial Commission will supply to the
appellant a Form 44
Application for Review upon which appellant must state the grounds for the appeal. The
grounds must be stated with particularity, including the specific errors allegedly
committed by the Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner and, when applicable, the pages in
the transcript on which the alleged errors are recorded. Failure to state with
particularity the grounds for appeal shall result in abandonment of such grounds, as
provided in paragraph (3). Appellants completed Form 44 and brief must
be filed and served within 25 days of appellants receipt of the transcript or
receipt of notice that there will be no transcript, unless the Industrial Commission, in
its discretion, waives the use of the Form 44. The time for filing
a notice of appeal from the decision of a Deputy Commissioner under these rules shall be
tolled until a timely motion to reconsider or to amend the decision has been ruled upon by
the Deputy Commissioner.
- Particular grounds for appeal not set forth in the application for
review shall be deemed abandoned, and argument thereon shall not be heard before the Full
Commission.
- Appellants Form 44
and brief in support of his grounds for appeal shall be filed in triplicate
with the Industrial Commission, with a certificate indicating service on
appellee by mail or in person, within 25 days after receipt of the
transcript, or receipt of notice that there will be no transcript. Thereafter, appellee
shall have 25 days from service of appellants brief within which to file a reply
brief in triplicate with the Industrial Commission, with written statement of service of
copy by mail or in person on appellant. When an appellant fails to file
a brief, appellee shall file his brief within 25 days after appellants
time for filing brief has expired. A party who fails to file a brief will
not be allowed oral argument before the Full Commission. If both parties appeal, they
shall each file an appellants and appellees brief on the schedule set forth
herein. The parties may file with the Docket Director a written stipulation
to a single extension of time for each party, not to exceed 30 days, if the matter has not
been calendared for hearing.
- After notice of appeal has been given to the Full Commission, any motions
related to the issues before the Full Commission shall be filed in
triplicate with the Full Commission, with service on the other parties.
- No new evidence will be presented to or heard by the Full Commission unless the
Commission in its discretion so permits.
- Cases should be cited by North Carolina Reports and, preferably, to Southeastern
Reports. Counsel shall not discuss matters outside the record, assert personal opinions or
relate personal experiences, or attribute unworthy acts or motives to opposing counsel.
- The Industrial Commission or any one of the parties with permission of the Industrial
Commission may waive oral argument before the Full Commission. In the event of such
waiver, the Full Commission will file a decision, based on the record,
assignments of error and briefs.
- A plaintiff appealing the amount of a disfigurement award shall personally appear before
the Full Commission to permit the Full Commission to view the disfigurement.
-
Briefs to the Full Commission shall not exceed 35
pages, excluding attachments. No page limit shall apply to the length of
attachments. Briefs shall be prepared entirely using a 12 point font, shall
be double spaced, and shall be prepared with non-justified right margins.
Each page of the brief shall be numbered at the bottom right of the page.
When quoting or paraphrasing testimony or other evidence in the transcript
of the evidence, a parenthetic entry in the text, to include the exact page
number location within the transcript of the evidence of the information
being referenced shall be placed at the end of the sentence citing the
information [Example: (T.p.38)]. When quoting or paraphrasing testimony or
other evidence in the transcript of a deposition, a parenthetic entry in the
text to include the name of the person deposed and exact page number
location within the transcript of the deposition of the information being
referenced shall be placed at the end of the sentence citing the
information. [Example: (Smith p.15)].
Rule 702
Appeal to the Court of Appeals
- Except as otherwise provided in N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-86,
in every case appealed to the North Carolina Court of Appeals, the Rules of Appellate
Procedure shall apply. The running of the time for filing and serving a notice of appeal
is tolled as to all parties by a timely motion filed by any party to amend, to make
additional findings, or to reconsider the decision, and the full time for appeal commences
to run and is to be computed from the entry of an Order upon any of these motions, in
accordance with Rule 3 of the Rules of Appellate Procedure.
- If the parties cannot agree on the record on appeal, appellant shall furnish the Chair
of the Industrial Commission, or his designee, one copy of the proposed record on appeal,
objections and/or proposed alternative record on appeal along with a timely request
to settle the record on appeal. The hearing to settle the record on appeal shall be held
at the offices of the Industrial Commission or by telephone conference.
- The amount of the appeal bond shall be set by the Chair or his designee, and may be
waived in accordance with N.C. Gen. Stat. §97-86.
Rule 702A
Remand from the Appellate Courts
When a case is remanded to the Commission from the appellate courts, each party
may file a statement with the Full Commission, supported by a brief if
appropriate, setting forth its position on the actions or proceedings, including
evidentiary hearings or depositions, required to comply with the court’s
decision. This statement shall be filed within 30 days of the issuance of the
court’s mandate and shall be filed with the Commissioner who authored the Full
Commission decision or the Chairman of the Industrial Commission if the
Commissioner who authored the decision is no longer a member of the Industrial
Commission.
Rule 703
Review of Administrative Decisions
- Orders, Decisions, and Awards made in a summary manner, without detailed findings of
fact, including Decisions on applications to approve agreements to pay compensation and
medical bills, applications to approve the termination or suspension of compensation,
applications for change in treatment or providers of medical compensation, applications to
change the interval of payments, and applications for lump sum payments of compensation
may be reviewed by filing a Motion for Reconsideration with the Industrial
Commission and addressed to the Administrative Officer who made the Decision or may be
appealed by requesting a hearing within 15 days of receipt of the Decision or receipt of
the ruling on a Motion to Reconsider. These issues may also be raised and determined at a
subsequent hearing.
- Motions for Reconsideration shall not stay the effect of the Order, Decision or Award;
provided, that the Administrative Officer making the Decision or a Commissioner may enter
an Order staying its effect pending the ruling on the Motion for Reconsideration or
pending a Decision by a Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner following a formal hearing. In
determining whether or not to grant a stay, the Commissioner or Administrative Officer
will consider whether granting the stay will frustrate the purposes of the Order,
Decision, or Award.
- Any review made by requesting a hearing shall be made to the Industrial Commission and
filed with the Industrial Commissions Docket Director. The Industrial Commission
shall designate a Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner to hear the review. The Commissioner
or Deputy Commissioner hearing the matter shall consider all issues de novo, and no
issue shall be considered moot solely because the Order has been fully executed during the
pendency of the hearing.
ARTICLE VIII. RULES OF THE COMMISSION
Rule 801
Waiver of the Rules
In the interest of justice, these rules may be waived by the Industrial Commission. The
rights of any unrepresented plaintiff will be given special consideration in this regard,
to the end that a plaintiff without an attorney shall not be prejudiced by mere failure to
strictly comply with any one of these rules.
Rule 802
Sanctions
- Upon failure to comply with any of the aforementioned rules, the Industrial Commission
may subject the violator to any of the sanctions outlined in Rule 37
of the North Carolina Rules of Civil Procedure, including reasonable attorney fees to be
taxed against the party or his counsel whose conduct necessitates the order.
- Failure to timely file forms as required by either these Rules or pursuant to the Act
may result in fines or other appropriate sanctions.
Rule 803
Procedure for Workers Compensation Rule Making by the Industrial Commission
Prior to adopting, deleting, or amending any Workers Compensation Rule of the
Industrial Commission which affects the substantive rights of parties, the Industrial
Commission will give at least 30 days notice of the proposed change in rules. Such
notice will be given by publishing, in a newspaper or newspapers of general circulation in
North Carolina, notice of such proposed change. Such notice will include an invitation to
any interested party to submit in writing any objection, suggestion or other comment with
respect to the proposed rule change or to appear before the Full Commission at a time and
place designated in the notice for the purpose of being heard with respect to the proposed
rule change.
ARTICLE IX. REPORT OF EARNINGS
Rule 901
Check Endorsement
If a self-insured employer, carrier or third party administrator places "check
endorsement" language on the back of an employee's check, the following language (or
similar language approved by the Industrial Commission) shall be used:
By endorsing this check, I certify that I have not worked for or earned wages from
any business or individual during the period covered by this check, or that I have
reported any earnings to the employer/carrier paying me workers' compensation benefits. I
understand that making a false statement by endorsing this benefit check may result in
civil or criminal penalties.
Rule 902
Notice
A self-insured employer, carrier or third party administrator shall not use check
endorsement language on the back of an employee's workers' compensation benefit check
unless the employee has been provided the following Notice sent by certified mail return
receipt requested:
Notice to Employee Receiving Workers' Compensation Benefits
This NOTICE is intended to advise you of important information you need to know if you
are receiving workers' compensation benefits.
Please TAKE NOTICE of the following:
(1) When you are receiving weekly workers' compensation benefits, you must report any
earnings you receive to the insurance company (or employer if the employer is
self-insured) that is paying you the benefits. "Earnings" include any cash,
wages or salary received from self-employment or from any employment other than the
employment where you were injured. Earnings also include commissions, bonuses, and the
cash value for all payments received in any form other than cash (e.g., a building
custodian receiving a rent-free apartment). Commission bonuses, etc., earned before
disability but received during the time you are also receiving workers' compensation
benefits do not constitute earnings that must be reported.
(2) You must report any work in any business, even if the business lost money or if
profits or income were reinvested or paid to others.
(3) Your endorsement on a benefit check or deposit of the check into an account is your
statement that you believe that you are entitled to receive workers' compensation
benefits. Your signature on a benefit check is a further affirmation that you have made no
material false statement or concealed any material fact regarding your right to receive
the benefit check.
(4) Making false statements for purpose of obtaining workers' compensation benefits may
result in civil and criminal penalties.
Rule 903
Employees Obligation to Report Earnings
A self-insured employer, carrier or third-party
administrator may require the employee to complete a
Form 90
Report of Earnings when reasonably necessary but not more than once every
six months.
The
Form 90 must be
sent to the employee by certified mail, return receipt requested, and include a
self-addressed stamped envelope for the return of the Form. When the employee
is represented by an attorney, the
Form 90 shall be
sent to the attorney for the employee and not to the employee.
The employee shall complete and return the
Form 90
Report of Earnings within 15 days after receipt of a
Form 90. If the
employee fails to complete and return the Report of Earnings within 30
days of receipt of the form, the self-insured employer, carrier or third-party
administrator may seek an order from the Executive Secretary allowing the
suspension of benefits. The self-insured employer, carrier or third-party
administrator shall not suspend benefits without Commission approval. If the
Commission suspends benefits for failure to complete and return a
Form 90
Report of Earnings, the self-insured employer, carrier or third-party
administrator shall immediately reinstate benefits to the employee with back
payment as soon as the Report of Earnings is submitted by the employee. If
benefits are not immediately reinstated, the employee should submit a written
request for an Order from the Executive Secretary instructing the self-insured
employer, carrier or third-party administrator to reinstate benefits. If the
employee’s earnings report does not indicate continuing eligibility for partial
or total disability compensation, then the self-insured employer, carrier or
third-party administrator may apply to the Commission to terminate or modify
benefits pursuant to Commission procedure, including filing a
Form 24,
36, and
33.
N.C. Industrial Commission · 4340 Mail Service Center · Raleigh, NC 27699-4340
Main Telephone: (919) 807-2500
· Fax: (919) 715-0282
NCIC Home Page: http://www.comp.state.nc.us/